Systematic Stockpicking is Back: Why This "Goldilocks" Market is Different
The headlines say the US economy is in a “Goldilocks” zone — growth up, inflation down. That’s true. But look under the hood, and the usual calm is replaced by violent churn.
This isn’t a random market wobble. It’s the collision of three powerful forces: extreme positioning unwinding, historic valuation gaps, and a productivity shock (AI) that is finally broadening out.
Understanding this chain reaction is your edge for the next few years.
The Four Pillars of the Rotation
1. Positioning Was Extremely Crowded
For years, the trade was simple: own U.S. mega-cap growth. The “Magnificent 7” became a consensus lifetime position. Hedge funds were net long tech at historic highs. Retail was concentrated.
When any trade gets that crowded, the reversal is violent—not because the fundamentals are bad, but because everyone tries to exit at once.
2. Relative Value Stretched to Breaking Point
The valuation gap between mega-cap growth and everything else (small caps, value, cyclicals) became historically wide.
At some point, mean reversion isn’t a theory—it’s a physical force. Money flows from overvalued to undervalued, and that flow is never smooth. It’s a dam breaking, not a faucet turning.
3. AI Is Democratizing (The Real Game Changer)
The first phase of AI was about infrastructure: Nvidia chips, data centers. That benefited a handful of mega caps.
The second phase is about application and productivity. AI is now helping industrials optimize supply chains, helping small caps automate service, helping manufacturers redesign factories.
This means the AI tailwind is broadening to sectors and market caps left out of phase one. Small caps and cyclicals aren’t just “cheap”—they now have a growth narrative for the first time in years.
4. The Rotation Has Fundamental Backing
This isn’t just a positioning flush or a value catch-up. It’s a fundamental rotation.
Small caps are leveraged to accelerating domestic growth. Industrials are benefiting from AI-driven efficiency. Cyclicals are pricing a genuine reflation in economic activity. When a rotation has fundamental backing, it’s not a short-term wobble — it’s a regime shift.
Why This Time Feels Different
This has the hallmarks of a structural regime shift, unlike the false dawns of 2013, 2016, or 2021.
Historical parallels:
Like 2000–2007: After the Nasdaq peaked, the next seven years weren’t a bear market for everything. They were a rotation out of overvalued large-cap tech and into energy, materials, industrials, and emerging markets. The winners of the previous decade became the losers. It was violent, but sustained.
Like 2009–2012: By 2011–2012, the market broadened in a way that punished the narrow “safe haven” trade. Banks, small caps, and cyclicals took over.
What Makes This Shift Sustainable
The Valuation Gap Is Generational: The Magnificent 7 traded at 30–50x earnings while small caps traded at 12–15x. When gaps are that wide, mean reversion tends to last years, not months.
The AI Story is Just Beginning: Phase one (infrastructure) benefited a handful of names. Phase two (application) benefits thousands of companies. Small caps adopting AI to compete is a multi-year narrative.
Domestic Cyclicals Have Tailwinds: With manufacturing reshoring, infrastructure spending, and energy independence, domestic cyclicals have a structural bid that didn’t exist in prior years.
Positioning Still Has Room to Run: Hedge fund and retail exposure to mega-cap tech has eased, but it’s not washed out. Institutional allocations to small caps are still below historical averages. This trade is in early innings.
The Violence is the On-Ramp
Sharp moves scare people. They feel like “something is breaking.”
But in regime shifts, the violence is the mechanism by which capital is forcibly reallocated. It’s the market’s way of prying investors out of consensus positions that became too comfortable.
The question isn’t “bull or bear?”
The question is: Are you positioned for the new regime, or are you still trading the old one?
This has the feel of a multi-year broadening, not a fleeting rotation. Stockpicking isn’t just back — it’s now the only game in town now!
If you found this useful, subscribe below to get these insights straight to your inbox every week.
Best regards,
Andreas